Pies
*Pies are MADE TO ORDER in a standard 9 inch pan*
Any pie can be made Gluten Free for an additional $5 (pastry crust, per crust) or $5 (graham crust)
Graham crust can be swapped for a pastry crust for $5
Pies marked with a * can be made dairy-free for an additional $2
Fruit Pies
Specialty Pies
Cream Pies
Choose Classic (top crust) or
crumb topped
Apple* - $24
Cherry* - $27
Peach* - $28
Strawberry* - $28
Blueberry* - $27
Made in a graham cracker crust unless otherwise specified
Banana Cream Pie - $22
Chocolate Cream Pie- $21
Coconut Cream Pie- $23
Key Lime Pie - $22
(graham crust)
Lemon Meringue - $22
(graham crust)
Pumpkin Pie* - $19
Pecan Pie* - $22
Sugar Free Pies
**Can only be made in a pastry crust**
Chocolate Cream Pie - $23
Banana Cream Pie - $24
Pumpkin Pie* - $22
Coconut cream pie
Want to place an order?
Please visit our "Ordering" page for information on placing orders
Bakery Disclosure: Not everything listed on our site is available in-store at all times. We are a small bakery and simply do not have the square footage required to have all the treats we can make on display at all times. For a list of treats we have on hand, call us or check our Facebook page. We are committed to keeping a fresh variety on display for your choosing. If you need a certain amount of goodies for an event or your personal enjoyment, we are always taking orders!
Allergy and Diet Friendly Notice
All of our products are produced on shared equipment.
We cannot with 100% certainty guarantee that items are free of any allergen contaminant. When placing an order, or visiting our bakery, please be sure to advise us of any and all allergies so we can properly handle your order.
Most of our recipes can be altered to accommodate gluten or dairy allergies or intolerances. For any other allergy, or diet friendly choices, please email us at MySimpleSweetsBakery@gmail.com, and let us know what you are looking for. We will be more than happy to help meet your needs. Ingredient substitutions can be made for an additional charge.